?

Log in

 
 
29 March 2009 @ 04:29 pm
Challenge 2, Round 8, Finals, Results  
Thanks a lot to everyone who voted, we can finally announce our...

ch4ndler is the winner
with 37 votes




jorge_2 is the runner-up
with 28 votes



Awards




Congratulations! You both did an amazing work and I hope you had fun! :)
If you want to read the comments for your last icons let me know.
 
 
 
stam_fan17stam_fan17 on March 29th, 2009 04:11 pm (UTC)
Congrats to both of you =D
You both did amazing! ^-^
JD: chace {smile♥}jorge_2 on March 29th, 2009 04:32 pm (UTC)
:D congrats to ch4ndler!
I'd love comments for my icons, thanks!

Both banners are awesome!
secret_vision: dh >> sexy backsecret_vision on March 30th, 2009 01:08 pm (UTC)
Congrats again my dear, you did amazing, thanks again for being such a great participant!
Your comments:
PART A
+ Great crop & color.
+ Both are blurry, but the colouring on the second is way more fascinating.
+ Pretty coloring.
+ Better cropping.
+ Because i prefer the focus on those two than on the whole group (as that seems a bit.. squeezed?)
+ The girls all look too squished together, the coloring on two really brings out marcia and dana's faces.
+ The colors are better & the quality is higher (i guess)
+ Only two of the girls are on it, and it's very ironic it's those two as in the show they're well frenemies.
+/

PART B
+ Great use of text.
+ Text doesn't overshadow the picture/cropping.
+ Too much light in the 2nd one.
+ 'cause i like the "movement" and the caption better.
+ 'Brave new world' is appropriate for the picture.
+ I like how the font matchs with the shirt.
+ I like the coloring, font and wording.
+ It reflects just perfectly Gabby's situation with her daughters.
+ I feel like 2 is almost a false advertisement for the show 'ugly betty' instead of DH.
+ Besides the nice colouring, the text sums up a lot Gaby's situation with her kids.
+/

PART C
+ Inaccurate crop and colour spoiled the 1st icon more than blurry text did to the second one.
+ Lovely cropping and coloring.
+ Plain and simple. It always work.
+ Mainly because the first one looks a bit... silly (?) to me, and the second one is sth i could imagine to upload for myself, it's just much more useful. I also prefer the sharping in that one.
+ The flowers in the first one take away too much from the bree's "power" over her gun, the text color also kind of mushes.
+ The way the picture is cropped.
+ I like the coloring better.
+ Keeping it very simple is nice for this icon.
+ The crop is great, focusing on Bree's face and the gun. The caption really suits the icon and there's nothing else to distract us from the subject.

PART D
+ Fresh coloring, i like it.
+/
♥ch4ndler on March 29th, 2009 05:34 pm (UTC)
WOW! Thanks everyone who voted for me! I'm flattered. And congratulations to jorge :)
The banner is just lovely and i would like to know my comments ;)
secret_visionsecret_vision on March 30th, 2009 01:21 pm (UTC)
Congratulations! You really deserved it :)
Your comments:
PART A
+ The picture works beautifully with the texture used.
+ For the coloring and the cropping.
+ I like the design at the top and the colouring's great.
+ Love the picture of the whole cast.
+ I love the group shot.
+ The pic and texture goes on really well.
+ I love the friendship theme between all of the housewives (instead of just Bree and Catherine).
+ Like that it shows them all.

PART B
+ Amazing color & funny use of text.
+ Better work with text.
+ Love the coloring and it's funny.
+ Great text and background.
+ The text color goes great with the bright greens of the icon.
+ The icon is simple and the text is clear. The caption is just pure genius.

PART C
+ Very original & creative composition.
+ Good use of the texture and text.
+ Great composition
+ Great text and background images.
+ The background is just gorgeous!
+ Like the color scheme & red dress.
+ The texture for the background is nice and well the text fits as we all know Bree is a NRA member and has four guns!
+/

PART D
+ Great use of text.
+ Just love the crop and neat text.
+ Nice use of text.
+ The white/cloudy texture works well with the emotions of Susan in that particular picture, so does the text.
+ Much more original coloring.
+ Because the caption just makes it THAT much better.
+ Great text, amazing colouring.
+ You really feel the loneliness for susan with the mist in the background, the desperate text really compliments it.
+ Simple, appropriate text.
+ The font looks beautiful.
+ Coloring and font are just gorgeous.
+ The caption reflex well on the scene and the icon.
+ The font is great and totally matches the whole icon.
+ Like seeing the whole dress & the word 'desperate'.
+ Helps to get the whole image/situation of Susan really desperate and the black-ish background where Bree's house should be, fits pretty much.